By The Sales Team, SPM

 

 

Two maintenance quotations can arrive for the same piece of work and still describe very different jobs. The totals may sit neatly next to each other on a procurement sheet, but the assumptions behind them may be miles apart.

That matters when price is the main point of comparison. Before deciding that one supplier is expensive and another is competitive, it is worth checking whether both have priced the same scope, the same level of testing, the same site conditions and the same responsibilities.

  1. The scope starts and ends in different places

A quotation should clearly state what work is included. One supplier may price only the requested maintenance activity, while another has allowed for related work needed to complete the job properly.

Read where each scope begins and where it ends. A lower total can make perfect sense once you discover that part of the work appears in one quotation and is absent from the other.

  1. The quotes are based on different assumptions about the equipment

The condition of equipment affects the work required. A supplier who has inspected an asset, reviewed available information or asked detailed technical questions may be pricing from a different understanding than one working from a short description.

Look at the assumptions stated in each proposal. If one price depends on the equipment being in a particular condition, that assumption deserves attention before comparing quotations.

  1. The level of testing is different

“Testing included” does not necessarily mean the same testing has been allowed for in every quotation. The type and extent of testing can vary according to the equipment, the work being carried out, and what needs to be confirmed before the asset returns to service.

The quotation should tell you enough to understand what will actually be tested. If that detail is missing, ask before treating two testing allowances as equivalent.

  1. Each supplier has planned around a different outage or access window

Time on site affects how work is organised. A quotation based on a continuous maintenance window can look very different from one that assumes restricted access, shorter working periods or work spread across several visits.

The agreed programme therefore belongs in the commercial comparison. If the suppliers have priced against different access conditions, their totals are answering different versions of the job.

  1. The resources behind the price are different

The number and type of people required for a maintenance job depend on the work involved. Specialist equipment, transport, and other resources may also be allocated differently.

A quotation rarely becomes clearer simply by comparing labour rates line by line. It helps to understand what resources the supplier believes are necessary to complete the work and why they included them.

  1. Parts, materials and consumables are treated differently

One quotation may include certain materials while another expects the client to supply them or prices them separately. Some items may also require confirmation once the equipment has been opened or assessed.

Check what is included in the price and what could still be added later. This is especially useful when one quotation appears substantially lower than the rest before work begins.

  1. Reporting and close-out are not the same

Physical maintenance is only part of what the client may require. Test results, maintenance records, reports and other close-out information can form part of the work expected after the site activity has been completed.

Look at what each supplier commits to provide once the job is finished. Differences here can affect how useful the maintenance work is to the people responsible for the asset afterwards.

  1. The exclusions place different responsibilities on the client

Exclusions are often where the biggest differences between quotations become visible. Access, permits, lifting arrangements, isolation requirements, accommodation, transport or other responsibilities may sit with the supplier in one proposal and with the client in another.

An exclusion does not automatically make a quotation weaker. It needs to be understood, because any responsibility transferred to the client still has to be arranged, managed and, in many cases, paid for somewhere.

A proper comparison takes more work than placing the totals side by side. Scope, assumptions, testing, access, resources, materials, reporting and exclusions all shape the price that eventually appears at the bottom of the page.

When those differences are made visible, the commercial conversation becomes much clearer. The client can see what each supplier has actually priced and decide on the work being offered, rather than on two totals that only appear to describe the same job.